Ratings & Reviews
4.5
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
Based on 232 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 167
Total 4 star reviews: 29
Total 3 star reviews: 24
Total 2 star reviews: 9
Total 1 star reviews: 3
84%would recommend these products
FitRated 0.3 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
Reviews Summary
Customers say these shorts are comfortable and soft with a nice stretch to the denim. Many praise the flattering fit, versatile style, and quality construction. The shorts work well for various occasions and body types. Common feedback notes these run large, with many customers sizing down one to two sizes for the best fit. Some mention inconsistent sizing across colors and occasional issues with waistband stitching or thread quality. Overall, most customers appreciate the comfort and style despite sizing challenges.
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
232 reviews
  • CF
    Christine F.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Maui 4" Short: White
    I recommend this product
    Usual Size Worn 4
    Height 5'3 - 5'5
    Body Type Athletic
    Size Purchased 4
    Rated 4 out of 5 stars
    1 week ago
    Inconsistent fit

    I love the Maui shorts 4” in the blue tide jean material, so I ordered them in white in the same size. They are a slightly looser fit in the white than the blue tide, so they get baggy by later in the day. I wish the sizing were more consistent, especially for the price! I appreciate the regular waist fit and length and overall they are beautiful shorts, just don’t fit me the same as the size 4 in the blue tide.

    FitRated 1.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
    Was this helpful?
  • NW
    Niki W.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Maui Short: Favorite Fade
    Usual Size Worn 8
    Height 5'6 - 5'8
    Body Type Athletic
    Size Purchased 6
    Rated 3 out of 5 stars
    2 weeks ago
    Cute fit but gigantic

    These COULD be perfect jean shorts. Great color (faded fade), quality, stretchy comfy. But they are enormous! I ordered an 8. Then I ordered a 6. Still ginormous. Wore them around the house and if I put my phone in a pocket they started to slide off my body. Would a 4 work? Not sure, but that seems a silly-small size for this 145lb, 5’6” girl who carries weight in my waist more than anywhere else.

    FitRated 2.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
    Was this helpful?
  • JD
    Julie D.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Maui Short: Beach Blue
    I recommend this product
    Usual Size Worn 6
    Height 5'6 - 5'8
    Body Type Athletic
    Size Purchased 6
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 weeks ago
    Great jean shorts!

    These shorts are comfortable and fit great!

    FitRated 0.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
    Was this helpful?
  • JD
    Julie D.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Maui Short: Dark Rinse
    I recommend this product
    Usual Size Worn 6
    Height 5'6 - 5'8
    Body Type Athletic
    Size Purchased 6
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 weeks ago
    Love these!

    These shorts are comfortable and fit great!

    FitRated 0.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
    Was this helpful?
  • JF
    Julie F.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Maui Short: Favorite Fade
    Usual Size Worn 10
    Height 5'6 - 5'8
    Body Type Curvy / Busty
    Size Purchased 10
    Rated 3 out of 5 stars
    1 month ago
    cute but not amazing

    These are cute and the fabric is soft and stretchy but the stitching around the top of the waist line is scratchy and the legs are more fitted than I expected them to be given the waist size.

    FitRated 0.0 on a scale of minus 2 to 2
    Was this helpful?
Sustainability Isn't A Feature - It's Our Foundation

When Carve Designs began in 2003, we didn't add sustainability to our checklist - we made it our core vision. That hasn't changed.

Sustainability Mission